In her recent piece, Enrollment and the Four Gaps, my colleague, Moira Kelly wrote, “[E]ach gap is the distance between what a school believes or intends and what is actually true.” If you haven’t read this piece, please do. I found it clarifying. It would be a great read for entire leadership teams as schools seek to understand and cohesively approach enrollment challenges.
Pairing Moira’s article with a conversation I led recently for middle leaders at the Tennessee Association of Independent Schools (TAIS) Annual Conference has brought my attention to the idea of gaps – specifically, gaps between strategic intention decided upon at the governance level and strategic execution that lives so often in the purview of middle leaders. Traversing the gap between intention and execution is a critical leadership challenge. And far too often the bridge that crosses this gap is more like the rotten rope bridge Indiana Jones barely makes it across than a marvel of modern design and safety built to sustain the weight of the school’s aspirations.
This is less a failure of individual people in middle management roles than it is of the people and systems that support their growth. The middle leaders I have known in my career are generally well-intentioned, knowledgeable, and dedicated. However, they are too often poorly trained in the areas of their strategic work, and heads of school have not prioritized the middle leaders’ close understanding of and alignment with strategy to the degree necessary. As a result, good strategy can get lost in the gap between intention and execution. Never to be found again.
Given the remarkable headwinds facing independent schools and the necessity of making the strategic intention manifest in the life of the school, schools must invest thoughtfully in the middle leaders who bear significant weight creating strategic success. This is not an optional investment for schools seeking to flourish in the years ahead.
In an earlier piece of writing, I described what I called the “spot on the horizon aspiration.” I was naming another sort of gap that exists often in a healthy tension in all schools, that is, the tension between what a school seeks to be versus what it currently is. The spot on the horizon is the strategic aspiration. Without strategically minded middle leaders, the aspiration simply stays on the horizon.
So, what does the investment in middle leaders look like:
Without mitigating the gap between strategic intention and execution, all strategy is doomed to fail, and middle leaders are critical in this effort. If you, as a head of school, are thinking about how you might help your middle leaders build their strategic muscles, our first and best advice is to bring them to the conversation by describing the challenge, and ask them what they need to be successful to become the partners the school needs.
By the way, in addition to keynoting, I presented on middle leaders at the recent Tennessee Association on Independent Schools conference. Below you can see that I dove into leadership vertigo and strategic leadership for middle leaders.