Articles

Now I Know Why It’s a Free House

Written by Moira Kelly | November 20, 2026

Almost 30 years ago, my soon to be husband, David, and I were living at Milton Academy. We were hosting Thanksgiving and it would be the first time that our families would meet. My parents were from out of state and were staying with us while David’s family lived about an hour away.

There were early signs that this would be a stressful day. As I was stirring fresh cranberries that morning to make cranberry sauce, David asked me what I was doing. When I told him I was making cranberry sauce he said that was fine, but we needed cranberry jelly. We didn’t have any. I was also informed we needed canned peas. I argued cranberry sauce and frozen peas were fine. It was made clear they were not the same thing. He grabbed his car keys and left in search of the peas and jelly.

My mother was peeling potatoes in the kitchen and thought we had a garbage disposal, but we did not. The result? The kitchen sink backed up. We called facilities, but given the holiday, we had to wait some time for an outside plumbing company to respond. In the meantime, we used the bathroom sink to try to keep the meal preparation on track. David returned with the cranberry jelly and the peas. Roto-rooter eventually arrived and unclogged the sink. My mother and I tried to make up for the lost time.

David’s family arrived. The families met. Drinks and hors d'oeuvres were served. People gathered in the kitchen as often happens at family gatherings even though I tried to shush them into the living room. I went to the dining room to tend to something, heard shouting, ran back to the kitchen only to find things were on fire. Literally on fire. The oven itself was on fire. Not a pot on the cooktop or the food in the oven, but the oven itself. I ran to get the fire extinguisher and yelled at my soon to be brother in law to open the oven door. He scooped up the partially cooked turkey and I sprayed the inside of the oven with the fire extinguisher. The fire was put out, but we had no functioning stove. We called facilities who again responded graciously, but there was little they could do that day.

It was time to crack open another bottle of red wine. I filled a big goblet. So much for making a good first impression. This was turning out to be a live version of a bad movie. We couldn’t finish cooking most things, but we did have a microwave. So we nuked the peas – canned and frozen. We served two different kinds of cranberries, some salad, and some pies and ice cream.

Word got to the head of school about the meeting of the families and our dinner woes. To try and help salvage the day, we were invited to go take over the athletic center. So most of us trudged over to the main campus, tossed around a basketball, took some spins on the ice, and made dark jokes about our current predicament. After an hour, we headed back to the house. While we were gone, David’s mother had used the bathroom. Unfortunately, the toilet backed up and flooded part of the downstairs. We worked on mopping things up and called facilities again. It was at this point that David’s nine year old niece said:

“Uncle David, now I know why it’s a free house.”

David’s family departed. Within a couple of days my parents left. We got a new stove. Facilities checked on the electrical system and could not have been nicer. Thanksgiving break came to an end and school was back in session. Our misadventures got a bunch of air time around campus. I knew we had become the object of much interest when in the coming weeks strangers would come up to me, introduce themselves, and offer their condolences. Those interactions were both surprising and reassuring. We had become the neighbors who had gone through a rough patch and people wanted us to know they were rooting for us.

The following year we hosted Thanksgiving again in the same house. When Gina arrived, now the ten year old niece, she carried a brown paper bag that I thought contained a large bottle of wine. I thanked her. She said, “Aunt Moira, you should open it now.”

I complied. It was not wine.

It was a new fire extinguisher. Thankfully, we didn’t need to use it that day.